Denotes vegetarian menu item.

Whole Pies

Prices are for: Small | Medium | Large
Additional toppings: $1.00 | $1.50 | $2.00

View our available toppings »

Create Your Own!

Enjoy a pie made just the way you want! Skilled hands prepare every pie to order and bake each of them on our stone hearth. Choose our traditional Thick or our Thin Crust. Both the dough and tomato sauce are handmade daily from the finest organic ingredients. Served with wisconsin, independently-farmed whole milk mozzarella

$6.30 | $10.00 | $13.00

Five Point

Pesto, roasted garlic, sundried tomatoes, mozzarella, parmesan & fontina cheeses

$9.60 | $15.40 | $19.60

The Aristocrat

Extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, cremini mushrooms, sharp cheddar, mozzarella, roasted organic tomatoes, roasted organic yellow onions, roasted potatoes & parmesan

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Big Star

Homemade cream of pesto, mozzarella, parmesan, gorgonzola, fontina, roasted red peppers & pistachios

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Hawaiian Punch

Organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, sopressata, mandarin oranges, pineapples, parmesan & ricotta

$9.60 | $15.40 | $19.60

Dante’s Inferno

Barbeuce sauce, mozzarella, all-natural barbecued chicken, bacon, organic red onions, roasted red peppers & parmesan

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

South of the Border

Homemade black bean salsa, roasted garlic, sharp cheddar, monterey jack, all-natural grilled chicken, organic yellow onions, diced jalepenos, roasted chilies, our homemade atomic sauce & cilantro

$11.00 | $18.00 | $23.00

Mr. Green Jeans

Extra virgin olive oil, cremini mushrooms, organic broccoli, mozzarella, organic roma tomatoes, organic red onions, black olives & fresh basil

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Super Duper

Homemade organic tomato sauce, monterey jack, sharp cheddar, pepperoni, italian sausage, all-natural ground beef & bacon

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Corporate Greed

Homemade cream of mushroom, cremini mushrooms, mozzarella, artichoke hearts, all-natural grilled chicken & organic yellow onions and parmesan

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Cow Tipper

Homemade organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, all-natural ground beef, black olives, parmesan & feta

$9.60 | $15.40 | $19.60

The Big Shindig

Homemade organic tomato sauce, cremini mushrooms, organic green peppers, organic red onions, pepperoni, ground beef, black olives, mozzarella and parmesan

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

The Buddha

Extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, organic baby spinach, sharp cheddar, organic roma tomatoes, organic zucchini, kalamata olives, parmesan & feta

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Tricky Ricky

Homemade organic tomato sauce, organic mushrooms, mozzarella, organic yellow onions, organic green peppers, black olives & parmesan

$9.60 | $15.40 | $19.60

The Gus

Porcini mushroom oil, roasted garlic, cremini mushrooms, organic portobellos, sharp cheddar, parmesan & fontina

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Thai Bhat

Homemade Thai curry sauce, all-natural grilled chicken, roasted garlic, chili pepper, baby corn, straw mushrooms, organic carrots, sharp cheddar, parmesan, fresh ginger & scallions

$11.00 | $18.00 | $23.00

Sergeant Scofflaw

Extra virgin olive oil, organic minced garlic, vine-ripened roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, parmesan & organic basil

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Sir Walter

Porcini mushroom oil, prosciutto, smoked gouda, roasted garlic, cremini mushrooms, mozzarella, parmesan & oregano

$10.60 | $16.80 | $21.60

Gluten Free Pies

Lilly’s proudly serves a 10″ gluten-free option for any of our pies. We hope you enjoy!

$2.00 additional.

Slices

Pizza by the Slice

Lilly’s delicious slices! Each is made to order and includes our homemade organic tomato sauce, and independently farmed mozzarella and parmesan cheeses. Top each one your way with any of over 70 toppings! (Limited availability on weekends!)

$2.30 per slice | $0.50 per each additional topping

View our available toppings »